The actress posted multiple videos from the night on Instagram, captioning it, “I promise he invited us to sing along. Thank you for the perfect night out, @jamestaylor_com, we loved every minute. ♥️🎄♥️.” Garner’s charm was fully displayed in the first video as she clapped and cheered for Taylor, demanding he returns for an encore. She yelled from her seat, “Don’t leave the stage. One more song!” before giggling with whoever was filming. Garner continued to cheer, saying, “Come back, come back!” As Taylor walked back on stage, Garner looked to her friend, adorably saying, “He loves me,” with a big smile on her face. Garner then joked, “Is he gonna call me up? Is this my time?” In another video, Garner sang along with Taylor and other audience members to the song “How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved by You).” Originally recorded by Marvin Gaye, Taylor recorded a cover that he released in 1975 on his album Gorilla, which was extremely successful and well-liked. Garner also shared clips of Taylor singing “Carolina in My Mind” and “Go Tell It on the Mountain.” She tagged Taylor in the post, and the singer commented, “🔥❤️,” which surely made Garner even happier after seeing him in concert. Actress Holly Robinson Peete wrote, “How does his voice just get better and better.” Many friends and followers shared their love for Taylor in the comments, with one writing, “I have seen him in concert several times and he is literally the only one I’ve seen who sounds better live than on their records. He’s magical.” Other fans just loved Garner and her excitement, as another comment read, “We need more Jennifer Garners in this world 🌎♥️.”